Background In this study, we analyze the performance of the Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) II, APACHE IV, Simplified Acute Physiology Score (SAPS) 3, and Mortality Probability Model (MPM)0 III in order to determine which system best implements data related to the severity of medical intensive care unit (ICU) patients.
Methods The present study was a retrospective investigation analyzing the discrimination and calibration of APACHE II, APACHE IV, SAPS 3, and MPM0 III when used to evaluate medical ICU patients. Data were collected for 788 patients admitted to the ICU from January 1, 2015 to December 31, 2015. All patients were aged 18 years or older with ICU stays of at least 24 hours. The discrimination abilities of the three systems were evaluated using c-statistics, while calibration was evaluated by the Hosmer-Lemeshow test. A severity correction model was created using logistics regression analysis.
Results For the APACHE IV, SAPS 3, MPM0 III, and APACHE II systems, the area under the receiver operating characteristic curves was 0.745 for APACHE IV, resulting in the highest discrimination among all four scoring systems. The value was 0.729 for APACHE II, 0.700 for SAP 3, and 0.670 for MPM0 III. All severity scoring systems showed good calibrations: APACHE II (chi-square, 12.540; P=0.129), APACHE IV (chi-square, 6.959; P=0.541), SAPS 3 (chi-square, 9.290; P=0.318), and MPM0 III (chi-square, 11.128; P=0.133).
Conclusions APACHE IV provided the best discrimination and calibration abilities and was useful for quality assessment and predicting mortality in medical ICU patients.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Association between hemoglobin/red blood cell distribution width ratio and acute kidney injury in sepsis and heart failure patients Petherson Mendonça dos Santos, Isabele Pardo, Maria Carolina Borges Pereira de Almeida, Rafael Santana de Oliveira, Fernanda Gabas Miglioli, Beatriz Mota Busnardo, Felipe Prieto Siqueira, Daniela Harsanyi, Andreia Pardini, Bruno Bravim, Anna Carolina de R PLOS One.2026; 21(2): e0331332. CrossRef
Acute Care Events During Systemic Cancer Treatment: Moving From Risk Prediction to Clinical Decision Support Using a Two-Model Approach Jacob Newton Stein, Soroush Fariman, Yishu Zhang, Bahjat Qaqish, Jennifer Elston Lafata JCO Oncology Practice.2026;[Epub] CrossRef
Physiology and health assessment, risk balance, and model for end-stage liver disease scores: Postoperative outcome of liver transplantation Raquel Hohenreuther, Andresa Thomé Silveira, Edison Moraes Rodrigues Filho, Anderson Garcez, Bruna Goularth Lacerda, Sabrina Alves Fernandes, Claudio Augusto Marroni World Journal of Transplantation.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Association between changes in corrected anion gap and mortality among critically ill patients during ICU stay: a multicenter observational study Yanli Hou, Ruohan Li, Jiamei Li, Jingjing Zhang, Jiajia Ren, Ya Gao, Xuting Jin, Yanni Luo, Xiaochuang Wang, Gang Wang Frontiers in Physiology.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Seraph® filter effectiveness in the treatment of circuit-related infections in ECMO patients—a single-center report Daniel Lovric, Ivan Situm, Vanja Nedeljkovic, Mate Mogus, Ante Erceg, Mirabel Mazar, Slobodan Mihaljevic, Vedran Premuzic Frontiers in Medicine.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Self-extubation in critically ill patients: new predictors identified in a multicenter retrospective study Carlos Eduardo Laverde-Sabogal, Carmelo José Espinosa-Almanza, Juan Pablo Álzate, Carlos Rosero, Margarita Arias, Julián Salazar Morales, Antonia Ramírez, Juan Camilo Aguado-Valderrama, Manuel E. Torres, Santiago Suárez Gómez, Daniela Patiño Colombian Journal of Anesthesiology.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Severe coronavirus disease 2019 and hypogammaglobulinemia: A prospective propensity-matched study of hemoadsorption Vedran Premuzic, Ivan Situm, Daniel Lovric, Pavle Roncevic, Sandra Basic-Kinda, Josip Batinic, Marko Kolic, Zoran Sabljic, Sabina Srbljinovic, Daniela Strinic, Katja Jankov, Nikolina Basic-Jukic, Slobodan Mihaljevic, Igor Aurer, Peter G Brindley, Thomas R Journal of Translational Critical Care Medicine.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Predicting Hospital Survival in Patients Admitted to ICU with Pulmonary Embolism Martin J. Ryll, Aurelia Zodl, Toby N. Weingarten, Alejandro A. Rabinstein, David O. Warner, Darrell R. Schroeder, Juraj Sprung Journal of Intensive Care Medicine.2024; 39(5): 455. CrossRef
Relationship between Patient Classification System and APACHE II Scores, and Mortality Prediction in a Surgical Intensive Care Unit U Ri Go, Sung-Hyun Cho Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing Administration.2024; 30(1): 67. CrossRef
Utilidad del uso del modelo MPM-II para predecir riesgo de mortalidad en comparación con SAPS-II en pacientes adultos en la unidad de cuidados intensivos Perla Marlene Guzmán Ramírez Acta Médica Grupo Ángeles.2023; 21(2): 115. CrossRef
Plasma and Urinary Biomarkers Improve Prediction of Mortality through 1 Year in Intensive Care Patients: An Analysis from FROG-ICU Beth A. Davison, Christopher Edwards, Gad Cotter, Antoine Kimmoun, Étienne Gayat, Agnieszka Latosinska, Harald Mischak, Koji Takagi, Benjamin Deniau, Adrien Picod, Alexandre Mebazaa Journal of Clinical Medicine.2023; 12(9): 3311. CrossRef
Effects of prior antiplatelet and/or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug use on mortality in patients undergoing abdominal surgery for abdominal sepsis Se Hun Kim, Ki Hoon Kim Surgery.2023; 174(3): 611. CrossRef
Validation of the APACHE IV Score for ICU Mortality Prediction in Dr. Sardjito Hospital During the Pandemic Era Rayhandika, Akhmad Yun Jufan, Yunita Widyastuti, Juni Kurniawaty Indonesian Journal of Anesthesiology and Reanimation.2023; 5(2): 72. CrossRef
Extracorporeal blood purification is associated with improvement in biochemical and clinical variables in the critically‐ill COVID‐19 patients Vedran Premužić, Jakša Babel, Danilo Gardijan, Ivana Lapić, Rajka Gabelica, Zvonimir Ostojić, Marin Lozić, Gordana Pavliša, Maja Hrabak, Josip Knežević, Dunja Rogić, Slobodan Mihaljević Therapeutic Apheresis and Dialysis.2022; 26(2): 316. CrossRef
Relation between red blood cell distribution width and acute kidney injury in patients with sepsis Marina Larissa Vettorello Ramires, Manoela Fidelis Batista Leite, Daniel Zu Yow Lo, Leonardo Bonilla da Silveira, Leonardo José Rolim Ferraz, Andreia Pardini, Araci Massami Sakashita, Andrea Tiemi Kondo, Guilherme Benfatti Olivato, Marcelino de Souza Durã Einstein (São Paulo).2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Prediction of hospital mortality in intensive care unit patients from clinical and laboratory data: A machine learning approach Elena Caires Silveira, Soraya Mattos Pretti, Bruna Almeida Santos, Caio Fellipe Santos Corrêa, Leonardo Madureira Silva, Fabrício Freire de Melo World Journal of Critical Care Medicine.2022; 11(5): 317. CrossRef
Reduction in the Rate of Mortality of Moderate to Severe COVID 19 Infected Patients with the use of Remdesivir - A Tertiary Care Hospital-Based Retrospective Observational Study Mahima Lakhanpal, Debpriya Sarkar, Ritesh Kumar, Isha Yadav Anesthesia Essays & Researches.2022; 16(3): 296. CrossRef
Phase Angle and Frailty are Important Prognostic Factors in Critically Ill Medical Patients: A Prospective Cohort Study S.J. Ko, J. Cho, S.M. Choi, Y.S. Park, C.-H. Lee, S.-M. Lee, C.-G. Yoo, Y.W. Kim, Jinwoo Lee The Journal of nutrition, health and aging.2021; 25(2): 218. CrossRef
The use of Chest Ultrasonography in Suspected Cases of COVID-19 in the Emergency Department Enrico Allegorico, Carlo Buonerba, Giorgio Bosso, Antonio Pagano, Giovanni Porta, Claudia Serra, Pasquale Dolce, Valentina Minerva, Ferdinando Dello Vicario, Concetta Altruda, Paola Arbo, Teresa Russo, Chiara De Sio, Nicoletta Franco, Gianluca Ruffa, Cinz Future Science OA.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Criticality: A New Concept of Severity of Illness for Hospitalized Children Eduardo A. Trujillo Rivera, Anita K. Patel, James M. Chamberlain, T. Elizabeth Workman, Julia A. Heneghan, Douglas Redd, Hiroki Morizono, Dongkyu Kim, James E. Bost, Murray M. Pollack Pediatric Critical Care Medicine.2021; 22(1): e33. CrossRef
Validation of the Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) II and IV Score in COVID-19 Patients Jeroen Vandenbrande, Laurens Verbrugge, Liesbeth Bruckers, Laurien Geebelen, Ester Geerts, Ina Callebaut, Ine Gruyters, Liesbeth Heremans, Jasperina Dubois, Bjorn Stessel, Edward A Bittner Critical Care Research and Practice.2021; 2021: 1. CrossRef
Relationship Between Mean Vancomycin Trough Concentration and Mortality in Critically Ill Patients: A Multicenter Retrospective Study Yanli Hou, Jiajia Ren, Jiamei Li, Xuting Jin, Ya Gao, Ruohan Li, Jingjing Zhang, Xiaochuang Wang, Xinyu Li, Gang Wang Frontiers in Pharmacology.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Blood purification therapy with a hemodiafilter featuring enhanced adsorptive properties for cytokine removal in patients presenting COVID-19: a pilot study Gianluca Villa, Stefano Romagnoli, Silvia De Rosa, Massimiliano Greco, Marco Resta, Diego Pomarè Montin, Federico Prato, Francesco Patera, Fiorenza Ferrari, Giuseppe Rotondo, Claudio Ronco Critical Care.2020;[Epub] CrossRef